
This guide is about the days after the letter from the Dental Council of Ireland arrives. For the inquiry, the sanctions and the High Court, read our Dental Council complaint guide for dentists.
What the Dental Council complaint letter tells you
Under section 38 of the Dentists Act 1985, the Council or any person can apply to the Fitness to Practise Committee for an inquiry into a dentist's conduct or fitness to practise. The committee first decides whether there is a prima facie case. Read the letter for:
- The allegation: what the patient or other person says happened, with the dates and the treatment involved.
- The ground: professional misconduct, or unfitness to practise because of a physical or mental disability, or one of the grounds added in May 2025.
- What the Council asks of you: the information or observations it wants, and by when.
The test for professional misconduct is narrow. The Council defines it as a serious falling short in the standards expected of a dentist, which must be capable of being proven beyond reasonable doubt. A complaint that is about a fee, access to records or redoing work is outside the Council's process; the Council points patients with those disputes to the Dental Complaints Resolution Service. Your reply can say so, politely, where it applies, but still answer every point about your conduct.
The response date
Reply by the date in the letter. Section 17.7 of the Council's Code of Practice regarding Professional Behaviour and Ethical Conduct (March 2022) says you must reply in a timely manner to any communication from the Dental Council or its committees, so a late reply is a conduct point in its own right. If you need longer to gather the records or take advice, write before the date passes, give the reason and propose a new date.
Your indemnifier
Call your indemnifier the day the letter arrives and send them a copy. Your indemnifier can advise on the reply, review a draft before it goes and tell you whether you need a solicitor. Two things to settle with them before you act:
- Contact with the patient. Do not contact the patient about the complaint. If the patient needs further care or asks for copies of records, handle that through your practice's procedure for records requests and keep a note of what was sent.
- Any offer to the patient. A refund or remedial treatment can be right for the patient, but it does not answer a complaint about your conduct, and it should never be tied to the patient withdrawing the complaint.
Keeping records as they are
Your reply rests on the dental chart, radiographs, photographs, treatment plans, consent forms, lab dockets, appointment and payment records, and any correspondence with the patient. Secure them all now, including records held on practice software or by a laboratory. Do not change an existing entry. If you need to add something, add it as a new note with its own date and the reason it was added. Altering a chart once you know of the complaint would hand the Council an allegation of dishonesty, which is more serious than a dispute about treatment.
Writing your observations
The Fitness to Practise Committee reads your reply when it decides whether there is a prima facie case. Write it after you have read the records and taken advice. A reply the committee can use:
- sets out the treatment in date order, from the records, with the clinical reasons for each decision;
- deals with every allegation and says clearly where your care fell short;
- names the parts of the Code of Practice that apply, such as consent, records or communication;
- sets out what you have changed since, with dates and evidence: an audit, a new consent form, peer review, a course certificate and your reflection on it;
- stays factual and professional, without criticising the patient.
If the committee finds a prima facie case and an inquiry follows, you receive written notice of the proposed evidence first; our Dental Council complaint guide covers that stage. For the equivalent letter to a pharmacist, see our guide to the PSI complaint letter.
CPD courses for a Dental Council complaint letter
Dealing with a Complaint or Investigation Professionally covers how to respond, and Ethics and Ethical Standards for Dentists and Dental Professionals is written against the Dental Council's Code of Practice. Each is €100 (€70 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, online and self-paced, with a dated certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics Ireland, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses that you can put in your reply. The same hours go into your CPD record: see CPD for dentists in Ireland. The Dental Council has no part in our courses. All the courses for dentists are on our Dental Council complaint page.
If the letter raises your conduct with patients or colleagues rather than one clinical event, read when a dentist should do a Dental Council professionalism course.
This guide is part of our Professional Misconduct hub.
If your observations need to show what you have understood about the complaint, read how a dentist shows insight to the Dental Council with an insight course.
If you plan to send evidence of the steps you have taken, read what a Dental Council remediation course needs to show.
If the complaint is about your conduct with a patient or a colleague, read when a dentist needs a Dental Council professional boundaries course.
Sources and further reading
- Dental Council: Fitness to Practice
- Dental Council: Making a complaint
- Dental Council: Code of Practice regarding Professional Behaviour and Ethical Conduct (March 2022)
- Dental Council: Annual Report 2024
Questions and answers
Can I settle with the patient directly after a Dental Council complaint?
Speak to your indemnifier before you offer anything. The Dental Council's process does not deal with disputes about fees, and the Council has no power to make a dentist redo work; for those, it points patients to the Dental Complaints Resolution Service, which is voluntary on both sides. A refund or remedial treatment does not answer a complaint about your conduct, and an offer should never be tied to the patient withdrawing the complaint.
How long do I have to reply to a Dental Council complaint letter?
Work to the date in your own letter. Section 17.7 of the Dental Council's Code of Practice regarding Professional Behaviour and Ethical Conduct says you must reply in a timely manner to any communication from the Council or its committees. If you need more time to gather records or take advice, ask in writing before the date passes.
Will a Dental Council complaint go to an inquiry?
Only if the Fitness to Practise Committee decides there is a prima facie case. If there is not, the Council may decide on no further action or direct that an inquiry be held. In 2024 the Council's annual report records two matters with no prima facie evidence and two sent forward for inquiry.
What counts as professional misconduct for a dentist in Ireland?
In the Dental Council's words, a serious falling short in the standards expected of a dentist, which must be capable of being proven beyond reasonable doubt. Treatment can fall below the expected standard without meeting that definition.
Should I write to the patient after the complaint?
Take advice from your indemnifier first. Do not contact the patient about the complaint itself. If the patient needs further care or copies of their records, deal with that through your practice's procedure and keep a note of what was sent and when.
This article is published by Healthcare Ethics Ireland for general information. It is not legal advice and does not replace advice from your indemnifier, your professional body or a solicitor about your own matter.
