
Doctors in Ireland show insight after a Medical Council complaint by setting out, early and in their own words, what went wrong, why it mattered to the patient, and what they have changed so that it does not happen again. Our Medical Council insight course, Insight for Fitness to Practise, is written to help you do that in a response to the Council. We write and issue the course; the Council does not run it.
What does the Medical Council mean by insight?
The Council's Sanctions Guidance (May 2024) is the clearest statement. Paragraph 6.1.1 says a doctor may show insight by giving evidence of their understanding of the problem, and it names an apology to anyone affected, made at an early stage, as one sign. It also lists the "timely development of insight during the investigation and hearing" among the mitigating factors. Insight is therefore something the committee looks for across the whole process, not only at the end.
Paragraphs 6.1.2 and 7.1.2 add that a doctor's culture or health may affect how insight is expressed, so the Council looks at the substance of what you say as well as the words.
What counts against a doctor?
Paragraph 7.1.1 of the Sanctions Guidance says a doctor is likely to lack insight where they refuse to accept their mistakes or to apologise, or where they give no evidence of attempts to remediate, or do so only immediately before or during the hearing. Paragraph 5.3 says a marked lack of insight or contrition may be an aggravating factor. The reason is set out at paragraph 8.1.3: the Council must consider whether there is an ongoing or future risk to the public. A doctor who cannot say what went wrong gives the Council no reason to believe it will not happen again.
Which duties in the Guide does insight answer to?
Insight is not a separate test; it answers duties already in the Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics (9th edition, 2024). The Guide's values ask you to "Be honest and open with patients when things go wrong". Paragraph 2.2 says that after an unintended outcome you must report the incident, learn from it and take part in any review, and paragraph 4.2 says you must practise and support a culture of open disclosure. A response that shows insight points to these duties and shows how you met them, or how you now meet them. Our guide to the Medical Council Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics sets out the chapters.
Where is insight read in the Medical Council process?
| Stage | Where insight is read |
|---|---|
| Authorised Officer's investigation | Your response to the complaint, sent after advice from your indemnifier, is the first place the committee sees what you understand. |
| Preliminary Proceedings Committee | The committee can take no further action, suggest mediation, invite an undertaking or refer the complaint to an inquiry. An undertaking not to repeat the conduct is easier to accept from a doctor who can explain it. |
| Fitness to Practise Committee inquiry | Insight does not decide whether an allegation is proven, but under the Sanctions Guidance it bears on the sanction. |
Paragraph 2.3 of the Guidance says sanctions are not meant to punish. The question at each stage is risk to the public, and insight is the evidence that the risk has been dealt with. For the stages in full, read the Medical Council complaint steps on one page.
What the insight course covers
The course runs over ten sections. It defines insight and shows how the Medical Council and the other Irish regulators use the word, then sets a poor demonstration beside a good one in cases about prescribing, records, money, boundaries and conduct towards a colleague. Later sections deal with the risk of repetition that a regulator sees when insight is missing, with self-assessment and reflective models, with the forms of evidence a doctor can gather, from CPD and audit to feedback from a patient or a colleague, and with how to set insight out in a portfolio or at a hearing. Reflective quizzes sit at the end of the first nine sections, and the final assessment leads to the dated certificate.
When a different course fits better
Insight is shown in writing, so pair this course with the Medical Council reflection course if you need help with the reflective statement itself. If you need to show the steps taken since, which paragraph 6.2.1 of the Sanctions Guidance names as mitigation, take the Medical Council remediation course.
Counting the insight course as CPD
Paragraph 61.3 of the Guide says that in planning your CPD you should reflect on your practice. Record the course with your professional competence scheme as part of the minimum of 50 CPD hours a year the Council sets.
If the complaint follows a patient safety incident, read what the HSE open disclosure policy asks of you.
Insight sits beside other evidence; read what a Medical Council remediation course should show the decision makers.
Sources and further reading
- Medical Council: Sanctions Guidance (May 2024)
- Medical Council: Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics for Registered Medical Practitioners, 9th edition (2024)
- Medical Council: Regulated Professions Act 2020 (complaints received on or after 6 May 2025)
- Medical Council: Professional competence, information for doctors
Key Takeaways
- Which course should I take for a regulator complaint about insight? Our insight course is written for doctors and follows the Medical Council's Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics; pair it with a written reflection that names the part of the code engaged.
- Will a course help my regulator investigation? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which the Preliminary Proceedings Committee and the Medical Council look at — strongest with a reflection and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
- When should I send the certificate and reflection? With your written response to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee — or before a fitness to practise inquiry or a review if the matter has gone further.
- Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics Ireland, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.
Frequently asked questions
How do doctors in Ireland show insight after a Medical Council complaint?
Doctors in Ireland show insight by explaining what went wrong, its effect on the patient and what they have changed, early in the process. The Sanctions Guidance names an early apology and evidence of understanding the problem as signs of insight.
What does the Sanctions Guidance say about a lack of insight?
Paragraph 7.1.1 says a doctor is likely to lack insight where they refuse to accept mistakes or apologise, or remediate only immediately before or during the hearing. Paragraph 5.3 says a marked lack of insight may be an aggravating factor.
At which stage of the Medical Council process does insight count?
At every stage: in your response to the Authorised Officer, when the Preliminary Proceedings Committee considers an undertaking, and at the sanction stage of an inquiry. It does not decide whether an allegation is proven.
Does the insight course count as CPD?
Yes. Record it with your professional competence scheme towards the 50 CPD hours a year the Council sets. Paragraph 61.3 of the Guide asks you to reflect on your practice when you plan CPD.
Is an apology an admission of the allegation?
The Sanctions Guidance treats an early apology to anyone affected as a sign of insight. How you word it, and how it relates to the allegations, is a matter to agree with your indemnifier or solicitor first.
This article is published by Healthcare Ethics Ireland for general information. It is not legal advice and does not replace advice from your indemnifier, professional body or a solicitor about your own matter.
