Complaints to your regulatorPreliminary Proceedings CommitteesFitness to practise inquiriesRemediation coursesDoctorsNurses and MidwivesDentists and Dental ProfessionalsPharmacistsAll Other Healthcare Professionals
Skip to content

Complaints and inquiries

The Medical Council’s Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics: What a Complaint Is Measured Against

The Medical Council's Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics for Registered Medical Practitioners (9th edition, 2024): what it is, how its six chapters are set out, what 'must' and 'should' mean, and how the Guide is used when a complaint is made about a doctor.

By Dr Shehzad Iqbal Published 5 November 2026 7 min read

The Medical Council’s Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics: What a Complaint Is Measured Against

This guide answers three questions: what the Guide is, how the 9th edition is set out, and how it is used when a complaint is made about you. The eight domains of good professional practice, which sit in the Guide's Appendix A, have their own page: read our eight domains guide for what each domain means and how CPD is recorded against them.

What is the Medical Council Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics?

The Guide is the Medical Council's statement of the standards it expects of registered medical practitioners. The Council describes it as "principles–based guidance on how to best work in partnership with patients", and says it is also useful for patients because it clarifies the standards of care they should expect from their doctor. The Guide states plainly that it is not a legal code and does not try to address every situation in practice. You still have a duty to comply with the laws and regulations that apply to you.

The current text is the 9th edition, dated 2024. The Council launched it in November 2023, and it applies from 1 January 2024 until the Council updates it; the 8th edition (as amended in 2019) applied before then. An Irish-language version and the earlier editions are on the Council's Guide page. The Council says it updates the Guide about every five years.

What do "must" and "should" mean in the Guide?

The Guide explains its own wording at the start. "You must" is used "where there is an absolute duty on you to comply with the guidance that follows." "You should" describes good practice in ordinary circumstances, and accepts that following it may not always be practical or that another approach may be right; in that case you use your judgement. The Guide adds that a doctor who acts in good faith in the patient's interests, and respects the patient's will and preferences, is well placed to explain and justify a decision if a concern is raised.

This matters in a complaint. A departure from a "must" is harder to explain than a reasoned departure from a "should", and a written record of why you chose another approach is part of that explanation.

How is the 9th edition set out?

After its front matter (Introduction; How the Medical Council expects you to use this guidance; Values and principles underpinning good professional practice; When standards are not met), the Guide has six chapters with 64 numbered paragraphs:

ChapterParagraphsTopics include
1. Good medical practice and patient safety1–12Patient safety, raising concerns, open disclosure, care in emergencies, leadership, doctors' own health and wellbeing
2. Consent13–24General principles, capacity, requirements for informed consent, who seeks consent, declining or withdrawing consent, physical and intimate examinations
3. Confidentiality25–32Disclosure within and outside the healthcare team, recordings by a doctor or a patient
4. Continuity of care33–46Prescribing, telemedicine, medical records and their retention, transfer of care
5. Professionalism47–59Professional boundaries with patients, communicating with the public, fees and advertising, medical reports, conflicts of interest, relationships with and concerns about colleagues
6. Regulatory requirements60–64Registration, maintaining professional competence, professional indemnity, language skills, complaints to the Medical Council

Appendix A reproduces the eight domains of good professional practice, and an index closes the Guide. Paragraph 61 ties the Guide to CPD: you must meet the Council's professional competence requirements, enrol in a scheme suited to your practice, and plan, carry out and record your CPD as your scheme operator directs. Hours, credits and the audit are covered in our professional competence scheme guide.

How is the Guide used in a Medical Council complaint?

The front matter section "When standards are not met" says the Council must act in the public interest when it becomes aware of a risk to patient safety, or where it needs to act to maintain public confidence or professional standards, and points to paragraph 64. Paragraph 64 lists the grounds on which a complaint can be considered. They include:

  • Professional misconduct: conduct that doctors of good repute would regard as disgraceful or dishonourable, or a serious departure from the standards expected;
  • Poor professional performance: a failure to meet the standards of competence that can reasonably be expected of a doctor practising that kind of medicine;
  • a relevant medical disability, a failure to comply with conditions of registration or with an undertaking, a contravention of the Medical Practitioners Act 2007, and certain criminal convictions.

The Guide then supplies the standard. The Council's Sanctions Guidance (published 28 May 2024) points to paragraphs of the 9th edition when it describes serious conduct: paragraph 60 for examples of dishonesty, paragraph 47 for professional boundaries and paragraph 12 for doctors' own health. The same guidance lists, as a mitigating factor, evidence that a doctor has kept to the Guide.

The steps a complaint goes through, from screening to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee (PPC) and a fitness to practise inquiry, are set out on our Medical Council complaint steps page; this guide does not repeat them.

How do you use the Guide in your response?

Read the complaint against the Guide's paragraphs before you write anything. For each concern, find the paragraph it engages, note whether the wording is "must" or "should", and say in your own words what the paragraph asks of you. Then set out, with dates, what you have done about it.

The Sanctions Guidance describes what the Council looks for. It says a doctor may show insight "by providing evidence of their understanding of the problem", and remediation by showing how they have addressed the concern and the steps taken to prevent a similar incident. It also says that evidence of remediation produced only immediately before or during a hearing may point to a lack of insight. A CPD course on the part of the Guide the complaint engages, finished early and followed by your own written reflection, is dated evidence of both. It also counts towards your professional competence scheme.

Which courses are written to the Guide?

Professionalism and Professional Standards for Doctors takes you through the key professional duties in the Guide so you can name the one a complaint engages. Where the complaint is about a single chapter, choose the course for it: Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice for Chapter 2, Confidentiality in Healthcare Practice for Chapter 3, or Professional Boundaries Course for paragraph 47. Each is €100 (€70 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, online and self-paced, with a dated certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics Ireland, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses. The Medical Council has no part in our courses. All the courses for doctors are on our Medical Council complaint page for doctors.

For how an ethics CPD course ties to the Guide when you face a complaint, read why a Medical Council ethics course matters for doctors facing a complaint.

This guide is part of our Professional Misconduct hub. Read also Medical Council complaint and fitness to practise inquiry and informed consent in Ireland.

Sources and further reading

Questions and answers

Which edition of the Medical Council Guide is in force?

The 9th edition (2024) has been the current text since 1 January 2024 and stays so until the Council replaces it. If your complaint concerns events before 2024, ask your adviser whether the 8th edition (as amended in 2019) is the relevant standard.

Is the Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics the law?

No. The Guide says it is not a legal code. You still have to comply with the law that applies to your practice, and the Guide notes that some laws and policies it refers to may be replaced over time. A breach of the Guide can still be the basis of a complaint to the Medical Council.

What is the difference between 'must' and 'should' in the Guide?

'You must' marks an absolute duty. 'You should' marks good practice that the Council expects in ordinary circumstances, while accepting that another approach may be right in a particular case. Where you depart from a 'should', be ready to explain your judgement.

Where does the Guide deal with complaints?

Paragraph 64, in Chapter 6 (Regulatory requirements), describes complaints made to the Medical Council about a doctor and lists the grounds on which a complaint can be considered, including professional misconduct and poor professional performance.

How do I cite the Guide in my response to a complaint?

Name the paragraph the complaint engages, for example paragraph 47 for boundaries or paragraph 13 for consent, say what the paragraph asks of you, and set out with dates what you have changed. A CPD course on that part of the Guide, with your own written reflection, is evidence you can attach.

This article is published by Healthcare Ethics Ireland for general information. It is not legal advice and does not replace advice from your indemnifier, your professional body or a solicitor about your own matter.

‹ All guides

Key Takeaways

Basket 0 Total €0 View basket
CPD CoursesBulk Buy OfferFrom €70 a course(Bulk Buy of 10)Save up to€300