
A complaint to the Medical Council is the start of a legal process with fixed stages, and the stage you are at decides what you should do. For complaints received on or after 6 May 2025 the process runs under the Regulated Professions (Health and Social Care) (Amendment) Act 2020: the Chief Executive Officer reviews the complaint, an Authorised Officer investigates it, the Preliminary Proceedings Committee decides whether there is cause for further action, and only a complaint that passes that committee reaches a fitness to practise inquiry before the Fitness to Practise Committee. The Council's own information for doctors says that between 80% and 90% of complaints opened and investigated do not progress beyond the Preliminary Proceedings Committee stage. This guide sets out each stage in the Council's words, the grounds a complaint must meet, the undertakings the committee can now offer, what an inquiry involves, the sanctions, and what a doctor can do at each stage to show insight and remediation.
If a complaint has been made about you, two courses are written for the response: Dealing with a Complaint or Investigation Professionally and Insight for Fitness to Practise. Each is €100 (€70 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, with a dated certificate you can put in your response to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee and record for your professional competence scheme. The courses for doctors facing a Medical Council complaint are on one page.
The grounds a complaint must meet
The Council's Grounds for Complaints page says a complaint "can only warrant action by the Medical Council" on the grounds set out in the Medical Practitioners Act 2007:
| Ground | The Council's definition |
|---|---|
| Professional misconduct | Conduct that experienced, competent and reputable doctors consider disgraceful or dishonourable; conduct that falls short of the standards of conduct expected of doctors. |
| Poor professional performance | A failure to meet the standards of competence, in knowledge and skill, the application of knowledge and skill, or both, that can reasonably be expected of doctors practising the kind of medicine the doctor practises. |
| A relevant medical disability | A physical or mental disability, including addiction to alcohol or drugs, that may impair the doctor's ability to practise medicine or a particular aspect of it. |
| Conditions and undertakings | A failure to comply with a condition attached to registration; a failure to comply with an undertaking given to the Council, or to take an action specified in a consent given after a previous inquiry. |
| The Act and convictions | A contravention of the Medical Practitioners Act 2007; a conviction in the State for an offence triable on indictment, or a conviction outside the State for an offence that would be triable on indictment in Ireland. |
The Council lists the kinds of complaint it investigates: "irresponsible or repeated mistakes in prescribing", a "serious failure to examine a patient properly", "inappropriate relationships and behaviour", misdiagnosis, inappropriate examinations, fraud or dishonesty, "serious breaches of a patient's confidentiality", any serious criminal offence, and clinical incompetence. It also lists complaints that are closed with no further action because they do not raise a concern about fitness to practise: fees, waiting times and appointment availability in non-urgent cases, the general medical scheme, historic incidents that cannot be investigated, matters the complainant has no direct knowledge of, repeated complaints about the same issue, misunderstandings, anonymous complaints that are not serious, and disagreements with a clinical opinion in a report for an employer or insurer. A complaint about a doctor being rude, the Council says, "may not reach the threshold of seriousness" for poor professional performance or professional misconduct.
The first stage: the CEO and the Authorised Officer
From 6 May 2025, every new complaint is investigated under the 2020 Act, which changed the preliminary stage of the process and nothing after it. The Council's page on the Act sets out five steps:
- Submission. The complaint is made to the Chief Executive Officer of the Council. It must concern a registered doctor, relate to a serious matter such as professional misconduct or poor medical care, and be made in good faith.
- Initial review by the CEO. The CEO assesses the complaint first. One that is "frivolous, vexatious, or not made in good faith" may be dismissed at this stage, and the complainant is told why. A serious criminal conviction goes straight to the Council. In the ordinary case the CEO appoints an Authorised Officer to investigate.
- Notification. If the complaint proceeds, you receive a copy of the complaint, a letter notifying you that an investigation is commencing, and a copy of the Preliminary Proceedings Committee's procedures. The complainant receives an acknowledgement, an information booklet and the same procedures.
- Investigation by the Authorised Officer. The officer may request documents or information from you, ask you to respond to specific allegations, interview you or third parties, review clinical records, and consult experts. The Council's older information for doctors, which still describes the role of the case officer, says the officer is neutral and independent and has no part in the committee's decision, and that a copy of the complaint and all information obtained is sent to the doctor "out of procedural fairness and to provide the doctor an opportunity to respond".
- Review by the Preliminary Proceedings Committee. Once the investigation is complete the file goes to the PPC, which "will decide if there is enough cause to take further action".
The Council says that "depending on how complex the complaint is, it can take several months" from receipt to a decision on what action to take. At any point, if the CEO or the PPC believes a doctor poses an immediate risk to the public, the case may be referred to the Council to consider a temporary suspension, and the Council can apply to the High Court for an order suspending a doctor's registration whether or not the doctor is the subject of a complaint.
The Preliminary Proceedings Committee's decision
The PPC "consists of both medical and non-medical members" and considers every complaint the Council receives. Under the 2020 Act it may:
- request further investigation or information, and adjourn its consideration;
- recommend informal resolution or mediation: the Council's outcomes page says the PPC considers mediation where it is of the opinion that the complaint does not warrant referral to the Fitness to Practise Committee and could be resolved by restoring the doctor-patient relationship. Mediation needs both parties' agreement, is carried out by an independent mediator, and if it breaks down the complaint is treated as closed rather than referred back;
- take no further action, or recommend that the complaint be referred to another body or authority, or that the doctor be referred to the Council's performance procedures;
- refer you to the Fitness to Practise Committee for an inquiry, where it believes there is a prima facie case and no informal resolution is reached;
- offer you an undertaking (below).
"Council approves each decision made during the complaints process." A decision at the investigation stage cannot be appealed; the Council's page for doctors says that in certain circumstances, for instance if new information comes to light, a new complaint can be made. Where the PPC refers a doctor to performance procedures, the Council's assessment can use on-site assessment, observed patient interactions, feedback from peers and patients and a review of records, and ends in a report with recommendations that the doctor then puts into an action plan.
Undertakings: the new way a complaint can end
This is the change the 2020 Act made that matters to a doctor whose complaint has substance. If the PPC does not refer the complaint to an inquiry, it may instead "invite you to enter into an undertaking". The Council's examples are:
- a commitment not to repeat the behaviour complained of;
- participation in a professional competence scheme, with specific steps to improve skills or performance;
- agreement to undergo medical treatment where relevant;
- agreement to accept a censure, a formal warning, from the Council.
"If the doctor accepts and signs the undertaking or gives their consent, the complaint process is considered complete. The case does not move forward to a full Fitness to Practise inquiry." A report summarising the complaint and what the doctor agreed to do goes to the Council. If the doctor refuses or does not respond, "the PPC can continue the process as though no offer of an undertaking was made", which can mean referral to an inquiry. An undertaking is therefore the point at which what you have already done since the complaint has its greatest effect: the committee is deciding whether a promise and a plan from you are enough to protect the public without a hearing, and a plan that is already under way, with a dated certificate and a written reflection, is easier to accept than one that is only proposed. Note also that a failure to comply with an undertaking is itself a ground for a later complaint.
The fitness to practise inquiry
If the PPC refers the complaint to the Fitness to Practise Committee and "serious failings are identified, an inquiry is held". The Council describes it as "similar to that of a court hearing, in that sworn oral evidence is given and allegations are presented to the FTP panel". The inquiry team has three members, two non-medical and one medical, with a legal adviser who advises on matters of law and "does not take part in the decision making process". The CEO's role is to present the evidence "in the public interest at all times", based on expert evidence, and the CEO "can only proceed with allegations which are supported by independent evidence". Both sides can call witnesses, including independent medical experts, and the committee can question them. At the end of the evidence the committee withdraws to decide, on the evidence given, whether each allegation is proven.
Inquiries are held in public, so anyone can attend; the Council can decide that a hearing is held in private or part private where that is in the public's interest, and the doctor, the complainant or a witness can apply for that. The complainant may be called as a witness. The Council publishes an inquiries calendar and past inquiries, and says it may share fitness to practise findings with other competent authorities internationally.
Sanctions, and the High Court
If the Fitness to Practise Committee finds one or more allegations proven, the Council "must impose one or more of the following sanctions":
| Sanction | Appeal and confirmation |
|---|---|
| Advise, admonish or censure in writing | No right of appeal to the High Court, and the Council does not need the High Court to confirm it. |
| Censure in writing and a fine not exceeding €5,000 | A right of appeal to the High Court. If no appeal is made, the Council must apply to the High Court for confirmation of its decision. |
| Conditions attached to the doctor's registration | |
| Transfer of registration to another division of the register | |
| Suspension of registration for a specified period | |
| Cancellation of registration | |
| Prohibition on applying for restoration to the register for a specified period |
The Council publishes guidance on the sanctions it imposes. At the sanction stage, as at the undertaking stage, the committee and the Council are weighing the risk of repetition, and the evidence that answers that question is what you have done since the complaint: the steps your practice has taken, the courses completed on the subject of the concern, and a reflection that shows you understand why it mattered.
What to do at each stage
| Stage | What helps |
|---|---|
| Letter of notification | Advice from your indemnifier or a lawyer first. Read the complaint and the PPC procedures. Gather the records. Do not contact the complainant. |
| Response to the Authorised Officer | A factual account that answers each allegation; where something went wrong, say so, say why, and say what has changed since. Attach the evidence of change: a dated course certificate, a practice audit, a change to a protocol. |
| PPC consideration | The committee reads the complaint, the investigation file and your response. A response that already contains insight and remediation gives the committee a reason to close the complaint, recommend mediation, or offer an undertaking rather than refer it. |
| Undertaking offered | Take advice, and treat the undertaking as a plan you can show you have begun. A professional competence commitment is easier to give when the first course is already done. |
| Inquiry | Legal representation. Evidence of remediation and reflection goes to sanction: it does not decide whether an allegation is proven, but it bears on what the Council then imposes. |
The same courses for professional competence
Every doctor in Ireland is, in the Council's words, "legally obliged to maintain their professional competence", and does so through a professional competence scheme. A course on the subject of a complaint is also relevant learning for that scheme, and the Council's own undertakings page names participation in a professional competence scheme as one of the steps a doctor can be asked to take. One dated certificate serves both files: the response to the PPC, and your professional competence record. Our guide to the professional competence scheme for doctors sets out the 50 hours, the four categories, the clinical audit and the Medical Council’s own audit.
Which courses fit
For the response itself, Dealing with a Complaint or Investigation Professionally, with Insight for Fitness to Practise and Reflection for Fitness to Practise for the written reflection. For the subject of the complaint: Ethics for Doctors and Professionalism for Doctors; Prescribing Guidance and Standards for a prescribing complaint; Ethical Boundaries with Patients and Colleagues for a boundary concern with a patient or a colleague; Confidentiality in Healthcare Practice; Probity and Honesty for Healthcare Professionals for a dishonesty allegation; and Ensuring Clinical Competence and Patient Safety for a performance complaint. For the plan that follows an undertaking, Ensuring No Repeat of Misconduct or Mistake. All of them are on the doctors' page.
To see where a professionalism CPD course fits at each stage of this process, read how a Medical Council professionalism course helps after a complaint.
If you have been asked for a written reflection, read how the reflection workshop helps you write a reflective statement after a complaint.
Professional boundaries course for Medical Council registrants
Our Professional Boundaries Course is the professional boundaries course for doctors in Ireland facing a complaint or a fitness to practise inquiry about a boundary with a patient or a colleague — a dual relationship, gifts, or contact online — and for professional competence. It is online and self-paced, 2 CPD hours, €100 (€70 with Bulk Buy 10), with a dated certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics Ireland, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion. It covers what the Medical Council’s Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics says about boundaries, boundary drift and how to prevent it, and how to write a response to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee that shows insight. Where the concern involves a colleague as well as a patient, Ethical Boundaries with Patients and Colleagues sits alongside it.
Sources and further reading
- Medical Council: Regulated Professions Act 2020 (complaints received on or after 6 May 2025)
- Medical Council: Preliminary Proceedings Committee
- Medical Council: Complaints information for doctors
- Medical Council: Complaints outcomes
- Medical Council: Grounds for complaints
- Medical Council: Fitness to practise inquiries
This guide is part of our Professional Misconduct hub. See also the Professional Boundaries hub. Read also sexual boundaries and sexual misconduct and boundary crossing vs boundary violation. For the whole process in one table, read the Medical Council complaint steps on one page; for a High Court suspension, interim suspension in Ireland; for the standards themselves, the Medical Council Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics; for a complaint about consent, informed consent in Ireland; for planning CPD, the eight domains of good professional practice.
For help with the written reflection that goes with your reply, read how a Medical Council reflection course helps with your written reflection.
Key Takeaways
- Which course should I take for a regulator complaint about fitness to practise? Our fitness to practise course is written for doctors and follows the Medical Council's Guide to Professional Conduct and Ethics; pair it with a written reflection that names the part of the code engaged.
- Will a course help my regulator investigation? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which the Preliminary Proceedings Committee and the Medical Council look at — strongest with a reflection and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
- When should I send the certificate and reflection? With your written response to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee — or before a fitness to practise inquiry or a review if the matter has gone further.
- Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics Ireland, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.
Frequently asked questions
What happens when a complaint is made to the Medical Council about a doctor?
For complaints received on or after 6 May 2025 the complaint goes to the Chief Executive Officer of the Medical Council, who reviews it first and can dismiss one that is frivolous, vexatious or not made in good faith. In the ordinary case an Authorised Officer is appointed to investigate: you receive a copy of the complaint, a letter that an investigation is commencing and the Preliminary Proceedings Committee's procedures, and you are given the opportunity to respond. The file then goes to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee, which decides whether there is cause for further action.
What are the grounds for a complaint to the Medical Council?
A complaint can only warrant action on the grounds in the Medical Practitioners Act 2007: professional misconduct; poor professional performance; a relevant medical disability; a failure to comply with a condition attached to registration; a failure to comply with an undertaking or a consent given after a previous inquiry; a contravention of the Act; and a conviction for an offence triable on indictment. The Council's page of examples includes irresponsible or repeated prescribing mistakes, serious failure to examine a patient, inappropriate relationships and behaviour, misdiagnosis, inappropriate examinations, fraud or dishonesty, serious breaches of confidentiality, a serious criminal offence and clinical incompetence.
What can the Preliminary Proceedings Committee decide?
The PPC may request further investigation or information, recommend informal resolution or mediation, take no further action, refer the doctor to the Fitness to Practise Committee for an inquiry, or offer the doctor an undertaking. The Council approves each decision made during the complaints process. The Council's information for doctors says that between 80% and 90% of complaints opened and investigated do not progress beyond the PPC stage.
What is an undertaking from the Medical Council?
Under the 2020 Act the PPC may, instead of referring a complaint to a fitness to practise inquiry, invite the doctor to enter into an undertaking: a commitment not to repeat the behaviour complained of, participation in a professional competence scheme or remedial steps to improve skills or performance, consent to medical treatment where relevant, or agreement to accept a censure. If the doctor signs, the complaint process is complete and a report goes to the Council; if the doctor refuses or does not respond, the PPC continues as though no undertaking had been offered.
What happens at a Medical Council fitness to practise inquiry?
An inquiry before the Fitness to Practise Committee is similar to a court hearing: sworn oral evidence is given and allegations are presented to a panel of three, two non-medical members and one medical member, with a legal adviser who does not take part in the decision. The CEO presents the allegations, based on expert evidence, and both sides can call witnesses; the Committee then decides whether the allegations are proven. Inquiries are held in public unless the Council decides to hold all or part in private.
What sanctions can the Medical Council impose?
If one or more allegations are proven the Council must impose one or more of: advice, admonishment or a censure in writing; a censure in writing and a fine of up to €5,000; conditions attached to the doctor's registration; transfer to another division of the register; suspension for a specified period; cancellation of registration; or a prohibition on applying for restoration for a specified period. Every sanction other than advice, admonishment or censure carries a right of appeal to the High Court, and the Council must apply to the High Court to confirm it if no appeal is made.
Can a course count for CPD as well as for a complaint?
Yes. A doctor in Ireland must maintain professional competence through a professional competence scheme, and a course on ethics, professionalism, communication, records, prescribing or boundaries with a patient or a colleague is relevant learning for that scheme. The same dated certificate goes in your response to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee or your submission at an inquiry, and in your professional competence record.
This article is published by Healthcare Ethics Ireland for general information. It is not legal advice and does not replace advice from your indemnifier, professional body or a solicitor about your own matter.
