
This guide is for optometrists and dispensing opticians who have received a complaint, or who want to know what the Optical Registration Board expects before one arrives. It covers who regulates opticians, how a complaint is made, which sections of the Board's codes an optical complaint engages, what happens next, and how remediation and CPD fit in. The full CORU process, stage by stage, is on our CORU fitness to practise guide.
Who regulates opticians in Ireland?
CORU, Ireland's regulator for health and social care professionals, registers optometrists and dispensing opticians through the Optical Registration Board. The Board has adopted two codes:
- the Code of Professional Conduct and Ethics for Optometrists; and
- the Code of Professional Conduct and Ethics for Dispensing Opticians, made as a bye-law (S.I. No. 47 of 2019).
CORU says the updated codes came into effect from midnight on Thursday 28 February 2019. Both codes have the same 26 sections, grouped under Conduct, Performance and Ethics, and both say that "a breach or breaches of this Code could be held to be professional misconduct or poor professional performance".
How is a complaint about an optician made?
CORU says a complaint can be made by anyone about a health and social care professional registered with CORU. It accepts complaints in writing on its Complaints Form, which must be signed and dated. CORU can only act where the incidents complained of are serious, and its fitness to practise process does not replace an employer's own complaints process.
CORU also lists what it cannot do. It cannot help with a claim for compensation, make a registrant apologise, look into complaints about clinics or other healthcare organisations, or give a detailed explanation of what happened. A dispute with an opticians' practice about a refund, a price or a product is raised with the practice. A complaint to CORU is about whether the registrant is fit to practise.
Which parts of the Optical Registration Board code does a complaint engage?
A complaint is read against the sections of your code it touches. These are the sections that relate to the work of an optical practice:
| Section | What it asks of you |
|---|---|
| 9. Act within the limits of your competence | Work within your knowledge, skills and experience, and refer a service user to another professional when a task is beyond your competence. |
| 11 and 12. Consent and capacity | Take personal responsibility for obtaining consent, give enough information in a form the person understands, respect a refusal, and presume capacity. |
| 13. Communicate effectively | Communicate with service users and others involved in their care. |
| 18. Keep accurate records | Keep accurate records of your work with each service user. |
| 24. Avoid conflicts of interest | Do not accept inducements that could reasonably be seen as affecting your professional judgement, do not direct public service users to private practice for personal or commercial benefit, and do not enter an agreement that could cause you to breach the code. |
| 26. Truthful advertising | Advertising must be truthful, accurate, lawful and not misleading; promote a product or service only on your professional opinion of the service user's needs; give full and accurate fee information before you agree to provide a service or product. |
Sections 24 and 26 matter in optical practice, where the same registrant can examine, advise and sell. Section 3 of the dispensing opticians' code also forbids using your professional position to form sexual, inappropriately emotional or exploitative relationships; our boundary crossing and boundary violation guide covers boundaries with a patient or a colleague, including dual relationships. For consent across all Irish regulators, see our informed consent guide.
What happens after a complaint is made?
The complaint is considered by the Preliminary Proceedings Committee, which may ask you for information and decides whether further action is required. If it is, the complaint may be resolved by mediation, where you and the complainant both consent, or referred to a Committee of Inquiry: a Professional Conduct Committee for conduct or competence, or a Health Committee where your health is in question. If a complaint is proven, the sanction is decided by the Health and Social Care Professionals Council, and the heavier sanctions need confirmation by the High Court. Each stage, your registration while the complaint runs, and the sanctions are set out in our CORU fitness to practise guide.
How should an optometrist or dispensing optician respond?
Your written response to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee is the first chance to show that you understand the concern. Name the section of your code the complaint engages, say what it asks of you, and set out, with dates, what you have already done: a change to how you explain fees or options, a new record template, a review of how you refer. Avoid arguing with the complainant; explain your reasoning and what you would do differently. A CPD course on the area of concern, finished early and followed by your own written reflection, is dated evidence of remediation that the committee can weigh. Ask your indemnifier or professional body for advice before you send the response.
What CPD does the Optical Registration Board expect?
Section 10 of each code asks you to keep your knowledge and skills up to date, to take part in continuing professional development on an ongoing basis, and to keep a record of it. The Board has published a CPD Guidance Document (2019), a CPD Support Document and an optometrist CPD Audit Record example showing the learning and recording it would expect if you are called for audit. The credits, the reflection your record must show and the audit deadline are covered in our CORU CPD requirements guide. A course you take after a complaint is recorded there too.
Which courses fit an optician complaint?
Dealing with a Complaint or Investigation Professionally is written for the response itself. Ethics and Ethical Standards for Healthcare Professionals fits a complaint about conflicts of interest, advertising or fees. Where the concern is about consent or the record, Privacy, Consent and Chaperone in Healthcare Practice and Documentation for Healthcare Professionals fit. Each is €100 (€70 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, online and self-paced, with a dated certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics Ireland, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses. CORU and the Optical Registration Board have no part in our courses. All the courses for CORU registrants are on our CORU fitness to practise page.
This guide is part of our Professional Misconduct hub. Read also interim suspension in Ireland.
Sources and further reading
- CORU Optical Registration Board: Code of Professional Conduct and Ethics for Optometrists
- S.I. No. 47 of 2019: Optical Registration Board Code of Professional Conduct and Ethics for Dispensing Opticians Bye-Law 2019
- CORU: Registration Boards publish updated Codes of Professional Conduct and Ethics
- CORU: About Fitness to Practise
- CORU: Limits of Fitness to Practise
- CORU: CPD for Dispensing Opticians and Optometrists
Questions and answers
Who do I complain to about an optician in Ireland?
Optometrists and dispensing opticians are registered by the Optical Registration Board at CORU, so a fitness to practise complaint about a registered optician goes to CORU. CORU takes complaints in writing on its Complaints Form, which must be signed and dated.
Can CORU get me a refund from an opticians' practice?
No. CORU says it cannot help with a claim for compensation, cannot make a registrant apologise, and cannot look into complaints about clinics or other healthcare organisations. A dispute about a refund or a product is raised with the practice itself.
Which code is an optometrist measured against?
The Optical Registration Board's Code of Professional Conduct and Ethics for Optometrists. Dispensing opticians have their own code from the same Board, in force from 28 February 2019 (S.I. No. 47 of 2019). Both codes have the same 26 sections under Conduct, Performance and Ethics.
Does a complaint go to a hearing?
Not in every case. A complaint can close at the first stage if the committee that screens it sees no need for further action, and some complaints are settled by mediation. A hearing before a Professional Conduct Committee follows only where the complaint is referred for an inquiry.
Do optometrists and dispensing opticians need CPD?
Yes. Keeping your knowledge and skills up to date is a duty in both optical codes, and you keep a record of the CPD you do so you can show it if you are selected for a CORU audit. A course taken after a complaint goes into the same record.
This article is published by Healthcare Ethics Ireland for general information. It is not legal advice and does not replace advice from your indemnifier, your professional body or a solicitor about your own matter.
