
An NMBI complaint and the fitness to practise inquiry that can follow it run on a route set by the Nurses and Midwives Act 2011, and NMBI's own pages describe each step of it. The complaint goes first to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee (PPC), which investigates with the help of a case officer and decides whether there is "sufficient cause to warrant further action". If there is, the matter is referred to the Fitness to Practise Committee (FTPC) for a fitness to practise inquiry, which reports to the Board; the Board imposes any sanction, and some sanctions must be confirmed by the High Court. This guide sets out the grounds a complaint must meet, what the case officer and the PPC do, the PPC's options and the Board's, what happens when a complaint is referred for an inquiry, the timelines, and what you can do at each stage to show insight and remediation.
If a complaint has been made about you, two courses are written for the response: Dealing with a Complaint or Investigation Professionally and Insight for Fitness to Practise. Each is €100 (€70 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours, with a dated certificate you can put before the PPC and record for your professional development. The courses for nurses and midwives are grouped on our NMBI complaint page.
The grounds a complaint must meet
NMBI's Grounds for complaints page lists the grounds in the Nurses and Midwives Act 2011 on which anyone, including the Board itself, may make a complaint to the PPC about a registered nurse or registered midwife:
| Ground | What NMBI's page says |
|---|---|
| Professional misconduct | Not defined in the Act; defined in case law (O'Laoire v Medical Council, applied to nursing in Perez v An Bord Altranais, 2005). Two tests: conduct that is "infamous or disgraceful in a professional respect", involving "some degree of moral turpitude, fraud or dishonesty" (the moral turpitude test); or conduct connected with the profession in which the nurse or midwife "has seriously fallen short, by omission or commission, of the standards of conduct expected amongst nurses or midwives" (the expected standards test). The judge in Perez added that "it is irrelevant that such misconduct is attributable to honest mistake". |
| Poor professional performance | Defined in section 2 of the Act: a failure "to meet the standards of competence (whether in knowledge and skill or the application of knowledge and skill or both) that can reasonably be expected" of a registered nurse or midwife carrying out similar work. A new ground under the 2011 Act. |
| Non-compliance with a code of professional conduct | Measured against the code "which was applicable at the time of the alleged events"; a code published later is not relevant. |
| A relevant medical disability | A physical or mental disability, "including addiction to alcohol or drugs", which may impair the ability to practise nursing or midwifery or an aspect of it. |
| A failure to comply with a condition | A condition attached to registration under the Act: at entry to the register, after a fitness to practise inquiry, or on restoration. |
| A failure to comply with an undertaking or a consent under section 65(1) | Agreements reached during a fitness to practise inquiry, which require the Board's approval. |
| A contravention of the Act, or of rules or regulations under it | Rules and regulations are published on NMBI's website as they are made. |
| A controlled drugs irregularity | An irregularity in the custody, prescription or supply of a controlled drug under the Misuse of Drugs Acts 1977 and 1984, or another drug likely to be abused. |
| A conviction for an offence triable on indictment | In the State, or outside it for conduct that would be such an offence here. The PPC must refer such a complaint to the Board at once, and the Board can act immediately if it considers the offence renders the nurse or midwife permanently unfit to practise. |
Two of those rows do more work than the others. "Poor professional performance" covers the error, the omission and the gap in knowledge that no one would call disgraceful; "non-compliance with a code" turns the Code of Professional Conduct and Ethics for Registered Nurses and Registered Midwives into a standard the PPC can measure a complaint against. The remediation work a nurse or midwife can do before the PPC decides is aimed at those two: showing that the standard of competence is now met, and that the code is now understood and applied.
The case officer and the PPC's investigation
NMBI's pages describe the first stage in the same terms twice: "If a complaint is made about you to the Nursing and Midwifery Board of Ireland (NMBI) it will be assigned to a case officer. The case officer assists the Preliminary Proceedings Committee (PPC) to manage the complaint and to carry out any investigations." The case officer keeps you updated on any decision made by the PPC or the Board. NMBI's advice at this point is direct: "you should contact your representative body and / or obtain legal advice before corresponding with NMBI in relation to the complaint".
The Investigating a complaint page lists what the case officer does:
- writes to the complainant to acknowledge the complaint, and may ask for copies of any documents it refers to;
- writes to you "enclosing a copy of the complaint and any supporting documentation received", and invites you to respond: "you are not obliged to do so".
Your response and documents go to the PPC. Before it decides, the PPC "may ask for further investigations to be carried out by the case officer", including "obtaining documentation and statements from witnesses", and may direct that a copy of your response be given to the complainant. The PPC may also require the complainant to verify the complaint by affidavit, require more information from the complainant, require you to give specified information, or invite you "to submit observations or supply any information which you believe should be considered by the PPC". NMBI's page says: "You will be provided with a copy of all documentation obtained by the PPC during the course of its investigation."
What the PPC can decide, and what the Board can do
Once the PPC has considered everything, NMBI's page says it "could do one or more of the following":
- refer the matter to the FTPC "for a sworn oral inquiry";
- form the opinion "that there is not sufficient cause to warrant further action";
- form the opinion that the complaint "should be referred to another body or authority";
- form the opinion that the complaint "could be resolved by mediation or other informal means".
For the second, third and fourth, the PPC must inform the Board of NMBI, which "may then do one or more of the following": decide that no further action is to be taken, direct the PPC to refer the matter to another body or authority, or refer information under a co-operation agreement entered into under section 15 of the 2011 Act. The case officer tells you the outcome.
So a complaint can end at the PPC stage in three ways that do not involve an inquiry, and the question the PPC is answering is whether there is sufficient cause to go further, not whether the allegation is proven. Evidence that the risk has been understood and addressed speaks to that question.
How long it takes
NMBI's pages acknowledge that "it can be very stressful and worrying for you" and say the PPC "is obliged to make reasonable efforts to ensure that it acts expeditiously", but that the time to investigate and decide varies with:
- the complexity of the complaint;
- the time needed to identify and obtain relevant documents;
- the time needed to arrange witness meetings and take statements;
- "waiting for any other investigations to be completed, for example, an investigation by An Garda Síochána".
You or your representative "may request an extension of time to respond to a complaint". If the complaint is referred to the FTPC, NMBI says the inquiry takes place within six to ten months of the PPC's decision in the ordinary case, "but this may vary, depending on the complexity of the complaint and how much preparation is involved". Our guide to the fitness to practise process in Ireland sets the NMBI route beside the other regulators'.
Referral to a fitness to practise inquiry
If the PPC or the Board directs that the complaint is to be referred for an inquiry, the case officer tells you, and the CEO's solicitors send you:
- notice of the allegations made against you;
- the evidence in support of the allegations;
- the proposed date of the inquiry and the venue;
- notification that you and/or your representative are entitled to be present and to defend yourself;
- notification that you can apply to have the inquiry held otherwise than in public.
"Any documents obtained during the course of the investigation will be disclosed to you." Inquiries "are held in public, except in certain circumstances": you may apply to the FTPC for the whole or part of the inquiry to be held in private, or for your identity to be anonymised, and the FTPC decides whether the application shows "reasonable and sufficient cause". If it is public, "any member of the public may attend", the media "will have the right to report on the matter", and "photographers and television cameras may be present outside the inquiry venue". The role of the FTPC, in NMBI's words, is "to consider all the relevant evidence at an inquiry and to make a decision in respect of any allegations made against the nurse or midwife".
The report, sanctions and the High Court
When the evidence has been heard the FTPC draws up a report stating whether or not the allegations are proven. If none is proven, "the Board will dismiss the complaint". If one or more is proven, the report "may also include a recommendation as to sanction", which the Board then considers; NMBI's Sanctions page says the Board "will impose one or more sanctions", and sets out the sanctions available and the factors it weighs in its Guidance on Sanctions (March 2018).
Two routes follow. "If the sanction to be imposed is an advice, admonishment or censure in writing, the Board does not need to apply to the High Court for confirmation of its decision." The other sanctions "must be confirmed by the High Court": the Board applies for confirmation, and "you will have twenty-one days to appeal this decision to the High Court. Appeals are held in public. In the event of an appeal, the case may be re-heard in full and witnesses may be called to give evidence at the appeal." The sanction stage is where evidence of insight and remediation has its last and clearest use: the Board's guidance weighs what the nurse or midwife has done since the events, and a report that records it is a report the Board reads before it decides.
What to do at each stage
| Stage | What helps |
|---|---|
| The case officer's letter | Contact your representative body or a solicitor before you write anything, as NMBI advises. Read the complaint against the nine grounds and note which it relies on. Gather the records. Decide, with your adviser, whether and how to respond. |
| Your response to the PPC | Facts in order, from the record. Where the record shows a shortfall, say so and explain it without excusing it. Then the remediation: a reflection on the events, a dated certificate from a course on the subject (medication management, record keeping, boundaries with a patient or a colleague, communication), supervision or a change in your practice. Ask for an extension if you need one to do this properly. |
| While the PPC investigates | Answer requests for specified information. Use the time: the courses and the reflection you complete now are in the file when the PPC forms its opinion. |
| Referral to an inquiry | Go through the notice of allegations and the evidence with your solicitor. Decide whether to apply for a private hearing or anonymity, and on what grounds. Prepare your evidence of insight and remediation for the FTPC and, if an allegation is proven, for the Board's decision on sanction. |
| After the Board's decision | If a sanction needs High Court confirmation, the twenty-one-day appeal period starts when the Board's decision is given. If conditions are attached, compliance with them is itself a ground of complaint if it fails, so keep the evidence of compliance from the first day. |
The same courses for professional development
Every registered nurse and midwife maintains professional competence, and ethics, professionalism and the subjects complaints turn on are part of it. Our courses are written against the regulator's standards and carry a dated certificate for 2 CPD hours, so the course you take for a complaint or fitness to practise inquiry is also one you can record as professional development, and a nurse or midwife with no complaint can take the same course for that purpose alone.
Which courses fit
For the response itself, Dealing with a Complaint or Investigation Professionally. For the question the PPC and the FTPC ask, Insight for Fitness to Practise and Reflection for Fitness to Practise. For the code, Ethics and Ethical Standards for Nurses and Midwives and Professionalism and Professional Standards for Nurses and Midwives. For the subject of the complaint: Prescribing Guidance and Standards for a medicines irregularity, Documentation for Healthcare Professionals for records, Ethical Boundaries with Patients and Colleagues for a boundary concern with a patient or a colleague, Probity and Honesty for a dishonesty allegation, and Ensuring No Repeat of Misconduct or Mistake for the plan that follows. All of them are on the courses page for nurses and midwives.
For the parts of the professionalism CPD course and how they match the Code, read what an NMBI professionalism course covers.
If you have been asked for a written reflection, read writing a reflective statement after a complaint, with the reflection workshop.
Professional boundaries course for NMBI registrants
Our Professional Boundaries Course is the professional boundaries course for nurses and midwives in Ireland facing a complaint or a fitness to practise inquiry about a boundary with a patient or a colleague — a dual relationship, gifts, or contact online — and for professional development. It is online and self-paced, 2 CPD hours, €100 (€70 with Bulk Buy 10), with a dated certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics Ireland, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion. It covers what the NMBI Code of Professional Conduct and Ethics says about boundaries, boundary drift and how to prevent it, and how to write a response to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee that shows insight. Where the concern involves a colleague as well as a patient, Ethical Boundaries with Patients and Colleagues sits alongside it.
Sources and further reading
- NMBI: Responding to a complaint
- NMBI: Investigating a complaint
- NMBI: Referral to an inquiry
- NMBI: Grounds for complaints
- NMBI: Sanctions (Guidance on Sanctions, March 2018)
- Nurses and Midwives Act 2011
If the complaint is about honesty, such as a record, a claim or an account given to a colleague, read whether an NMBI probity course is enough for an honesty concern.
This guide is part of our Professional Misconduct hub. See also the Professional Boundaries hub. Read also sexual boundaries and sexual misconduct and boundary crossing vs boundary violation. After a drug error, read medication error by a nurse: what happens next; for a High Court suspension, interim suspension in Ireland; for a complaint about consent, informed consent in Ireland. If the case officer's letter has just arrived, read NMBI complaint letter: what to do first.
Key Takeaways
- Which course should I take for a regulator complaint about fitness to practise? Our fitness to practise course is written for nurses and midwives and follows the NMBI Code of Professional Conduct and Ethics; pair it with a written reflection that names the part of the code engaged.
- Will a course help my regulator investigation? A course is evidence of insight and remediation, which the Preliminary Proceedings Committee and NMBI look at — strongest with a reflection and changes in practice. No course can guarantee an outcome.
- When should I send the certificate and reflection? With your written response to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee — or before a fitness to practise inquiry or a review if the matter has gone further.
- Can I finish the course before my deadline, and does it count as CPD? Yes — it is online and self-paced, a CPD course with a certificate issued by Healthcare Ethics Ireland, part of Healthcare Ethics Courses on completion.
Frequently asked questions
What happens when a complaint is made to NMBI about a nurse or midwife?
Every complaint about a registered nurse or registered midwife goes to the Preliminary Proceedings Committee (PPC). A case officer is assigned, acknowledges the complaint, and writes to you with a copy of the complaint and any supporting documents, inviting you to respond. The PPC considers the complaint, your response and any further investigation, and forms an opinion on whether there is sufficient cause to warrant further action. If there is, it refers the matter to the Fitness to Practise Committee for an inquiry.
What are the grounds for a complaint to NMBI?
The Nurses and Midwives Act 2011 sets nine grounds: professional misconduct; poor professional performance; non-compliance with a code of professional conduct; a relevant medical disability; a failure to comply with a condition; a failure to comply with an undertaking or a consent given under section 65(1); a contravention of the Act or rules made under it; an irregularity in the custody, prescription or supply of a controlled drug or another drug likely to be abused; and a conviction for an offence triable on indictment.
What can the Preliminary Proceedings Committee decide?
After considering all the documentation the PPC can refer the matter to the Fitness to Practise Committee for a sworn oral inquiry; form the opinion that there is not sufficient cause to warrant further action; form the opinion that the complaint should be referred to another body or authority; or form the opinion that it could be resolved by mediation or other informal means. For the last three it must inform the Board, which can decide that no further action is to be taken, direct a referral to another body, or refer information under a co-operation agreement.
How long does an NMBI complaint take?
NMBI says the time varies with the complexity of the complaint, the time needed to obtain documents and witness statements, and whether another investigation, for example by An Garda Síochána, must finish first. You or your representative can ask for an extension of time to respond. If the complaint is referred for an inquiry, NMBI says the inquiry takes place within six to ten months of the PPC's decision in the ordinary case, depending on complexity and preparation.
Is an NMBI fitness to practise inquiry held in public?
Inquiries are held in public except in certain circumstances. You can apply to the Fitness to Practise Committee for all or part of the inquiry to be held in private, or for your identity to be anonymised, and the committee decides whether the application shows reasonable and sufficient cause. If it is public, any member of the public may attend and the media may report on it.
What sanctions can NMBI impose, and does the High Court have to confirm them?
If the Fitness to Practise Committee finds an allegation proven, its report may recommend a sanction and the Board decides. An advice, admonishment or censure in writing does not need High Court confirmation. The other sanctions listed on NMBI's Sanctions page must be confirmed by the High Court; the Board applies for confirmation and you have twenty-one days to appeal, with the appeal held in public and the case possibly re-heard in full.
Do remediation courses count for professional competence as well?
Yes. A course on the subject of the complaint, with a dated certificate, is evidence of insight and remediation for the PPC or the Fitness to Practise Committee, and the same course is professional development you can record. Each course is €100 (€70 with Bulk Buy 10) for 2 CPD hours.
This article is published by Healthcare Ethics Ireland for general information. It is not legal advice and does not replace advice from your indemnifier, professional body or a solicitor about your own matter.
